blog




  • Essay / Analysis of Judge Dee as a Good Magistrate

    The “Judge Dee Famous Cases” revolved around a very prominent district magistrate named Judge Dee Goong An, a man famous for his ability to solve mysterious cases . Judge Dee dug deep to solve each case and succeeded because he combined the three philosophies of Legalism, Taoism and Confucianism. These philosophies provided him with important morals, techniques and strategies for dispensing justice in the region. Legalism, Taoism, and Confucianism all played a vital role in enabling Judge Dee to be an effective magistrate. Without these three elements, he would not have succeeded in his affairs and would not have maintained order and stability throughout the region. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on “Why Violent Video Games Should Not Be Banned”? Get the original essayOne of the main rules of the philosophy of legalism was corporal punishment. Judge Dee used this effectively when he punished crime suspects in order to expedite the flow of cases, which maintains peace and stability in the region. Thanks to these techniques that he used, he was able to quickly make the guilty confess. For example, during his investigation into the double murder case, Judge Dee “ordered the police officers to give Director Pang one hundred lashes of heavy bamboo” so that he would confess to his part in the crime (15). Because of this, Judge Dee eliminated another suspect in the murder case and was able to continue his investigation. Furthermore, when he ordered Hsu Deh-tai to be brought to trial for the murder of "The Strange Corpse", Judge Dee managed to get him to confess by inflicting "fifty lashes with the fine rattan" and the “great torture” on the body. cross (172). Although Hsu Deh-tai denied all allegations of having had an adulterous relationship with Ms. Djou, he eventually confessed his guilt and provided Judge Dee with the evidence needed to convict Ms. Djou as well. As a result, Judge Dee proved the culprits guilty and was able to solve the murder and close the case. Additionally, by punishing criminals, it would have prevented future crimes from occurring. Citizens would be hesitant and afraid to break the law because of what they saw when Shao Lee-huai, Hsu Deh-tai, and Ms. Djou received their cruel punishments for their crimes. With this deterrent effect, Judge Dee was able to maintain peace, stability and order in Chang-Ping. Although Judge Dee used physical methods to solve cases, he also turned to Taoism when there were particularly difficult cases. Taoism played a vital role in the book when Judge Dee was at a loss for how to continue his investigation. Because Taoism focused on a natural way of living and man's connection with nature, Judge Dee was able to use this philosophy to his advantage on several occasions. For example, during his investigation into the "Strange Corpse" case, he had to find Bee Hsun's grave among many burial mounds. However, to do so, Judge Dee conversed with the universe and said, "If Bee Hsun died a natural death, we probably won't find his grave." But if he was ignominiously murdered, his soul must still hover near his grave. corpse, and will manifest itself in one way or another” (45). Then, after saying a silent prayer, "there appeared a dark shape with indistinct outlines, floating towards them in the air", which "stopped near a solitary mound, somewhat apart from the others" (45) . It turned out to be Bee Hsun's grave and with this discovery, Judge Dee was able to conduct an autopsy to find the cause of death. Furthermore, while the autopsy was.